Who are the best real estate agents in Brooklyn Heights?
We've asked ChatGPT this 14 times over the past 14 days. It doesn't give the same answer twice, so instead of one day's list, here's how often it named each person. The Scott / Robles Team came up most — 12 times out of 14.
Named most often
ACROSS 14 ASKS
01The Scott / Robles TeamDouglas Ellimannamed 12 of 14 times (86%)
02Deborah L. RiedersCorcorannamed 11 of 14 times (79%)
03Michael GidalyDouglas Ellimannamed 11 of 14 times (79%)
04Paul JohansenCorcorannamed 11 of 14 times (79%)
05The Mendelis Saliba (Modern Solutions) TeamCompassnamed 11 of 14 times (79%)
06Natalie RabaaBrown Harris Stevensnamed 2 of 14 times (14%)
07Deborah RiedersCorcorannamed 1 of 14 times (7%)
08The DuPree TeamCompassnamed 1 of 14 times (7%)
09Greg MireCompassnamed 1 of 14 times (7%)
10Rhea CohenBrown Harris Stevensnamed 1 of 14 times (7%)
11Jill Seligson BraverBrown Harris Stevensnamed 1 of 14 times (7%)
12Nancy GiddinsBrown Harris Stevensnamed 1 of 14 times (7%)
The most recent answer, in full
ASKED OCTOBER 30, 2026
01Deborah RiedersCorcoran GroupLongtime top Brooklyn Heights broker, high sales
02Natalie RabaaBrown Harris StevensConsistent top Brown Harris Stevens producer
03Jill Seligson BraverBrown Harris StevensExperienced neighborhood specialist and award-winning broker
04The Scott / Robles TeamDouglas EllimanHigh-volume Douglas Elliman team, strong Brooklyn Heights record
05Ria BrowneCompassRealTrends-recognized Compass agent active in Brooklyn Heights
Shortlist of widely recommended real estate agents and teams serving Brooklyn Heights, Brooklyn.
Why two lists? Because ChatGPT rarely says the same thing twice. Ask it this question on two different days and most of the names change — across every question we track, only about one name in five survives to the next day. So the list at the top, counting how often each person comes up, is the more honest answer. The one below it is simply the most recent time we asked.
All of these names are ChatGPT's, not ours. We didn't pick them, we can't change them, and nobody paid to be here. How we do this.